My wife sent me a link today from the Wall Street Journal Online. It deals specifically about Fora.tv but winds its way into the discussion of content.
I like the last paragraph of the article:
Great, gripping documentaries, such as the PBS “Nova” series or some of the latest BBC imports are expensive to produce, which is why we see them so infrequently on television and not at all online, at least not as original programming. But the Web is supposed to be all about boundless choice. For folks who get tired of short clips of dogs chasing their tale, their choices are beginning to multiply.
The podosphere does need to be about diversity. Not for its own sake, but to offer the listener choices. These choices not only mean a difference in subject, but a difference in quality of presentation.
I have been asked to be a “guest lecturer” at a class at Franciscan University of Steubenville. Dr. Jim Coyle has been doing a great job of teaching these students not only the technical aspects of podcasting, but the art of storytelling as well. I have been listening to their projects that are available online.
What I noticed is there is a lot of energy and ideas. Over time, the students have experimented with different techniques both in recording and editing. The projects are very interesting from a technical point of view. I have listened to about 2/3 of them at this point. What I have noticed, by-and-large, is the lack of reflection. There is a lot exposition - the telling of stories. There is not enough reflection on what the stories mean to them and how the event(s) changed them.
I remember listening to an interview with Julie Snyder who is the Senior Producer of the This American Life Radio Program and Executive Producer of the TV show. She mentioned how she received a great story. She just thought it was great. It was funny, poignant, and powerful. The only thing, she reflected, was there was no lasting impact on the person who told the story. It didn’t change them, or their life in any apprecable way. In effect, it was an anecdote one would tell at a party. While these can be fun or interesting, they are not the stuff of feature stories.
As Ira Glass has said, the pace of his stories are anecdote, anecdote, reflection. No more than two stories before a search for meaning. Next time you listen to This American Life, see if you can pick up this rhythm.
By-the-way, I had the chance to watch an episode of This American Life on Showtime while I was out of town last weekend. Wow, it almost makes me want to get cable, just so I can watch the show. It was awesome.
PS. If you got to the This American Life page on Showtime, you can watch the first episode of the TV version.
Kewl. Very, very kewl.
Tags: Video, Storytelling, This American Life, Franciscan University of Steubenville, Media Creation, Kewl, Jim Coyle | 1 Comment »